Beard Balm vs Oil – The Ultimate Guide – December, 2022

by Jamie Wilson
beard-oil-vs-beard-balm

Reviewed & updated: October 19, 2022 by Jamie Wilson BA

Beard balms and beard oils are pretty similar in their application, and both are easy to use while not being too pricey. However, you will get a different outcome with both of these products. Figure out which of these will suit your beard better, and find your perfect beard oil or your perfect beard balm down below!

Editors Pick: Honest Amish Beard Balm Leave-in Conditioner

Sale
Honest Amish Beard Balm Leave-in Conditioner - Made with only Natural and Organic Ingredients - 2 Ounce Tin
  • Hand Crafted in the USA
  • Softens Coarse and Rogue Hairs
  • Stops the Itch and Eliminates Beardruff
  • The BEST for your beard - GUARANTEED!

Your beard maintenance can be fun, as well as easy! Just use this highly-sold and loved beard balm, one of the best-selling kinds on Amazon. This one has been handcrafted in the USA. It helps with rouge hairs and will make coarse hair soft and shiny! With regular use, this beard balm can prevent unwanted itchiness that you may experience. This beard balm is made with organic ingredients and is infused with Virgin Argan, Avocado, Almond oil, as well as shea butter. It is made in the USA and there are no chemicals, preservatives or fragrances in this tube. 

PROS:

  • Affordable
  • You get 2 ounces of product
  • Made in the USA
  • Filled with high-quality ingredients
  • No chemicals or fragrance
  • Will make your hair soft over time

CONS:

  • May irritate those who have nut allergies

Editors Pick: Honest Amish – Classic Beard Oil

Sale
Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil - 2 Ounce
25,839 Reviews
Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil - 2 Ounce
  • Hand Crafted in the USA
  • Organic Virgin Argan, Golden Jojoba and 6 More Premium Hydrating Oils
  • All Natural and Organic Ingredients
  • Softens Beard and Conditions Skin

When it comes to moisturizing your beard, go for this oil. It is another well-loved and sold product by Honest Amish. This item was handcrafted in the USA. It is an organic and natural oil that will soften and condition your beard! It is also filled with hydrating oils, virgin argan oil, as well as jojoba oil. The manufacturer also offers a full refund if you are not satisfied with your purchase! The oil is pretty affordable and can be used by any beard lengths, thickness, or types.

PROS:

  • Made in the USA
  • High-quality & nourishing oil
  • Organic and natural
  • Filled with top-class ingredients
  • Affordable

CONS:

  • The scent is quite strong, may irritate guys who dislike strong scents
  • What Is The Difference Between Beard Oil And Balm?
  • Make your beard game strong and fierce with the right beard products! However, comparison wise, here’s what you should know before making your next purchase:
Beard oilBeard balm
Has an oily consistencyHas a matte waxy consistency 
Helps you style your beardShapes your beard
Can promote beard growthMostly used for styling purposes
Treats ingrown hairDoesn’t treat ingrown hair
Reduces dandruffMakes the beard soft 
Hydrates the skin & beardOnly hydrated the beard
Should be applied twice a dayShould be applied whenever you’re styling your beard

When Should I Use Beard Balm? When Should I Use Beard Oil?

You should apply a beard balm to slightly damp skin. The best time? Just after showering and after washing your face. Never apply the product onto dry skin since it won’t sink in as easily, nor as deeply. Apply your beard balm before you’re out the door!

You can apply beard oil twice a day onto cleansed skin. Make sure you’ve previously showered or a least have washed your face. Your skin will feel a lot smoother and your pores will easily sink in all the product. 

———— Top 5 Beard Balm Options ————

Cremo Styling Beard Balm, Forest Blend

Sale
Cremo Styling Beard Balm, Forest Blend, Nourishes, Shapes And Moisturizes All Lengths Of Facial Hair, 2 Ounce
  • Styles, shapes and tames beards that have grown past the scruff stage
  • Designed with blend of beeswax, shea butter and essential oils
  • Just a small dab locks in moisture and keeps beard looking shiny and healthy
  • Woodsy forest scent won’t overpower your other fragrances

This balm will nourish different beard types, styles, and lengths. It is pretty affordable and available in two different scents. You can get either the mint or forest blend kind. This beard bam has 2 ounces of product and is one of the most affordable balms on the market. Thanks to its addition of Shea butter as well as beeswax, your beard will look a lot more healthy and soft + it will have all the necessary shine. 

PROS:

  • Super affordable
  • Two different kinds to choose from
  • Safe to use on any beard type or length
  • You can use it on your mustache
  • Will remove fly-aways

CONS:

  • Not for you if you dislike the mint scent

Honest Amish – Heavy Duty Beard Balm

Sale
Honest Amish - Heavy Duty Beard Balm - 2 Ounce - Beard Conditioner
  • Hand Crafted in the USA
  • Softens and Conditions, Tames Unruly Beard Hairs
  • All Natural and Organic Ingredients
  • Works great with Honest Amish Original Beard Wax

Your facial hair will love this beard balm, especially if you usually gravitate towards organic ingredients. This is a 2-ounce bottle that has been handcrafted in the USA. You will also love the scent and the blend of all the natural oils + the manufacturer offers a money-back guarantee in case you end up disliking the product. You will love to see your hair growth improve over time + this balm will last you for quite some time.

PROS:

  • Filled with organic ingredients
  • Has a soothing scent
  • Made with natural oils
  • You get 2 ounces of product
  • Affordable
  • Made in the USA

CONS: 

  • A bit too thick/waxy when compared to other balms

Beard Balm – Rocky Mountain Barber

Beard Balm - Rocky Mountain Barber - 100% Natural - Premium Wax Blend with Cedarwood Scent, Nutrient Rich Bees Wax, Jojoba, Tea Tree, Coconut Oil
  • Cedarwood Scent - Our Cedarwood beard balm features real cedarwood essential oil for its signature cedarwood scent.
  • Convenient 2 oz tin - Our Cedarwood beard balm comes to you in a rugged 2 oz tin and fits anywhere for on the go grooming.
  • Simple Ingredients - Our Cedarwood beard balm features simple ingredients so you can feel good about what you’re using on your beard.
  • Crafted in Small Batches - Made in small batches to ensure you receive a beard balm made with the freshest ingredients possible.

Get rid of stubble hairs with this balm. You will also love the smell of cedarwood, which is its main ingredient! It is filled with natural ingredients and essential oils which will keep your beard looking and feeling amazing. All ingredients have been sourced across North America and will allow you to style your beard with ease. Also, thanks to its minerals and vitamins, the balm will alleviate itchiness (in case you have any)! You will get 2 oz of product at a reasonable price point.

PROS:

  • Natural ingredients
  • Has jojoba oil, tea tree, as well as coconut oil extracts
  • Affordable
  • Highly-sold
  • Can be used on any bear types or lengths
  • Has a soothing cedarwood scent

CONS:

  • The formula can be a bit drying on some skin types

PREMIUM Beard Balm Butter and Wax Formula For Men

Styling Beard Balm - Organic and Moisturizing Beard Butter with 12 Hour Hold | Works with All Ethnicities & Hair Colors | Reduces Skin Irritation & Flaking - Invigorates Beard Growth | 60g
  • FAST MELT INFUSION TECHNOLOGY: SUITABLE FOR ALL BEARD COLORS - When the crystal beard butter is rubbed between your fingers, it warmly melts and blends to enhance the VIBRANCE of any hair color. Works...
  • VERSATILE FOR MULTIPLE LOOKS - ANYBODY can instantly style their own unique look after showering, trimming or performing any morning routine. Simply work the beard styling balm between your hands and...
  • GLOBALLY AWARDED & BACKED BY RESULTS - 100% Organic, 0% Alcohol, and Animal Cruelty-Free. If you don't notice obvious improvement in your beard within 30 days then send the beard conditioner back to...

Some beard care products will come in stylish jars, such as this one! This is a premium beard balm that is available in either 60 or 100-gram bottles. You can have thicker strands and a fuller beard + this product will treat any split ends that you may have in your beard. It is suitable for any and every beard colors and length. In fact, over 90% of people have noticed a difference in just one application! Once applied onto your strands, this beard balm will leave you with nourished strands for up to 12 hours! It is organic and lightweight and is also cruelty-free.

PROS:

  • Two different sizes available
  • Organic & lightweight
  • Cruelty-free
  • Safe to use on any beard types
  • Will keep your beard nourished for 12 hours
  • Keeps your beard moist 
  • Stylish jar

CONS:

  • The scent of the wax may be a bit too strong, floral or feminine even to some

Magic Beard Balm Leave-in Conditioner by Mountaineer Band

Mountaineer Brand Conditioning Beard Balm for Men, Leave-in Beard Conditioner, Beard Butter for Men with Essential Oils, Shea Butter & Beeswax, Premium Beard Care Products, 2 Oz, Citrus & Spice Scent
  • LOOK GOOD FEEL GOOD: Mountaineer Brand Beard Balm combines all natural ingredients to condition your beard and skin. It hydrates and soothes dry itchy skin and repairs short or long dry damaged beard...
  • TAME THE MANE: Remove a thumbnail amount and rub with your palms to liquify. Work the blend of beeswax, butters, and essential oils into the hair from roots to ends. Let it absorb into your beard and...
  • BEARD SOFTENER: So simple, add to your daily grooming routine and leave in for a fuller beard appearance and manageability without feeling greasy or sticky. Leaves hair hydrated with a healthy shine....
  • LEAVE-IN DAILY CONDITIONING: All little goes a long way! Manage your style using the convenient premium balm that comes in a jar for easy storage. The subtle clean citrusy smell makes a great useful...

Shape your beard with ease and with this magic beard balm! It is available in six different scents, perfect for everyone’s personal preference! You can choose the following scents: citrus & spice, lime & sage, original, WV coal, pine tar, or timber. This balm will give you the all-day nourishment while also maintaining your beard, no matter its length! With regular use, your beard will appear a lot more moisturized, as well as soft. The balm is handmade in the USA (Virginia) and has 100% natural oils, as well as botanical butter and beeswax.

PROS:

  • Made in the USA
  • Natural & filled with high-quality ingredients
  • You can choose between six different kinds and scents
  • For any beard length
  • Good price point
  • You get 2 ounces of product

CONS:

  • A bit too thick consistency-wise

———— Top 5 Beard Oil Options ————

Viking Revolution Beard Oil Conditioner

Sale
Viking Revolution Beard Oil Conditioner - All Natural Unscented Argan & Jojoba Oils - Softens, Smooths & Strengthens Beard Growth - Grooming Beard and Mustache Maintenance Treatment, 1 Pack
  • Tame Your Beard: Even the burliest of beards can be controlled with our beard oil conditioner. Restore softness and shine for a smooth and frizz-free beard or mustache in seconds.
  • No Itching or Scratching: Get rid of the dreaded beardruff! Add a few drops of beard oil treatment and your beard will feel excellent as well as look great all day long!
  • No Scent Clash: We've made our beard grooming oil scent-free to avoid overwhelming fragrance mixes with cologne or face washes, and it's non-greasy too.
  • 100% Natural: We've put together the perfect beard conditioner blend of Argan Oil and Jojoba Oil to give you the badass beard you deserve.

If you are on a lookout for beard oil, why not give this one a chance? It is a pretty affordable oil by Viking Revolution which comes in the 1 OZ packaging. This is the 100% organic and natural product that is filled with Argan Oil and Jojoba oil. There is no harsh scent which means that everyone can use this beard oil with use. This is also a non-greasy product that can remove beard dandruff! If you are on a lookout for a liquid product that can come in handy after every shower, this is it!

PROS:

  • Organic and natural
  • Doesn’t feel too sticky
  • Can remove beard dandruff
  • Affordable
  • Filled with nourishing oils
  • Great for men who have coarse hair or similar issues

CONS: 

  • May clog your pores at first

Fragrance Free Beard Oil & Leave In Conditioner

Beard oil usage is pretty simple and straightforward. However, this model has the handy dropper pump which will distribute an even amount of product onto your fingers. This beard oil is pretty moisturizing and will eliminate itchiness from your beard, as well as dandruff! Its main ingredients are jojoba oil and Moroccan argan oil. The product is free from any parabens, fragrance, as well as GMOs. It hasn’t been tested on animals and is vegan-friendly. The bottle has 1 fl OZ of product and is safe to use on your mustache.

PROS:

  • Vegan & hasn’t been tested on animals
  • Free from parabens and fragrance
  • Can be used on your beard and mustache 
  • Has nourishing oils as its active ingredients
  • The manufacturer offers a money-back guarantee
  • Has a practical dropper pump

CONS: 

  • You shouldn’t apply it too often

Cremo Beard Oil, Forest Blend – Restores Moisture

Cremo Beard Oil, Revitalizing Cedar Forest, 1 fl oz - Restore Natural Moisture and Soften Your Beard To Help Relieve Beard Itch
  • Moisturizes and conditions your beard and the skin underneath to reduce beard itch
  • Keeps your beard and face smelling fresh and clean with aromatic cedar forest scent
  • Designed for beards of all lengths
  • For longer beards, oils replaces lost natural moisture, nourishing dry, damaged hair and hydrating the skin beneath.

Women love when guys smell manly, and sometimes beard conditioners and moisturizes can’t get the deal done! This is why you may love (and should use) this beard oil. It is available in three different scents: mint, forest blend, or you can go for the unscented kind (perfect if you are sensitive or prone to allergies). Thanks to its natural blend of Argan oil and Jojoba oil this product will leave your beard and mustache moisturized while being flake-free, and there will be no irritation!

PROS:

  • Three different scents and kids to choose from
  • There will be no inflammation for people with sensitive skin types
  • Great moisturizer for your beard & mustache
  • You only need two drops to get the perfect outcome
  • Filled with high-quality ingredients
  • Great price point

CONS: 

  • Not for you if you have super thin or sparse strands

Shea Moisture Beard Conditioning Oil

Sale
Shea Moisture Beard Conditioning Oil
  • Nourishes: Organic oils seep into the skin and keeps it healthy and moisturized
  • Moisturizes: The conditioning oil moisturizes skin and hair to give it a shine which is hard to miss
  • Rejuvenates: Maracuja oil along with Shea oils rejuvenates skin cells and promotes cell growth for a healthier look
  • Frizz-free: This conditioning oil makes hair smoother and frizz-free and fights the roughness along beard edges

If you are looking for something that can be moisturizing for the skin and nourishing for your beard, you will love this Shea Moisture beard oil! This is an organic oil that is filled with Maracuja oil and Shea oil. With frequent use, your beard will look frizz-free and you will experience no roughness whatsoever. The formula is non-greasy and it will not leave a sticky residue. There are no parabens, phthalates, sulfates, or mineral oil in this product. Also, there has been no animal testing in the making. With your purchase, you will get 3.2 fl oz of product.

PROS:

  • Moisturizing and nourishing
  • Hasn’t been tested on animals
  • Free of parabens and sulfates
  • Organic
  • Fights the frizz with ease
  • You get 3.2 fl oz of oil

CONS:

  • May be a bit too oily 

Beard Farmer – Growther Beard Growth Oil

Beard Farmer - Growther Beard Growth Oil (Grow Your Beard Fast) All Natural Beard Oil
  • Grow Your Beard Super Fast
  • All Natural Oils
  • Made in the USA
  • Conditioning Topical Rub

Beard oils and balms have a thicker texture, and this one may suit mature men a bit better. This is a natural beard oil that is made in the USA and it will suit any beard lengths. The product is filled with pure and cold-pressed essential oils which will stimulate the hair growth over time and with regular application. The product has a minimal scent and it will suit people who have sensitive skin or who are prone to irritation.

PROS:

  • Made in the US
  • Has cold pressed oils
  • Stimulates the hair growth
  • Perfect for combating frizz
  • Safe to use on people who have sensitive skin
  • No scent

CONS:

  • A bit pricey
  • May not suit guys who have patchy beards

Conclusion

Enjoy a mess free application with the right product! A combination of both of these can stimulate beard growth. You can also remove beardruff and prevent the itch from your follicles! So, which of these 10 beard products is your favorite? A beard styling balm and a beard pomade will suit any beard length and texture, just find your ideal product in the article!

Our Best Picks
Top Pick
Honest Amish Beard Balm Leave-in Conditioner - Made with only Natural and Organic Ingredients - 2 Ounce Tin
Beard Balm - Rocky Mountain Barber - 100% Natural - Premium Wax Blend with Cedarwood Scent, Nutrient Rich Bees Wax, Jojoba, Tea Tree, Coconut Oil
Best Price
Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil - 2 Ounce
Styling Beard Balm - Organic and Moisturizing Beard Butter with 12 Hour Hold | Works with All Ethnicities & Hair Colors | Reduces Skin Irritation & Flaking - Invigorates Beard Growth | 60g
Title
Honest Amish Beard Balm Leave-in Conditioner - Made with only Natural and Organic Ingredients - 2 Ounce Tin
Beard Balm - Rocky Mountain Barber - 100% Natural - Premium Wax Blend with Cedarwood Scent, Nutrient Rich Bees Wax, Jojoba, Tea Tree, Coconut Oil
Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil - 2 Ounce
Styling Beard Balm - Organic and Moisturizing Beard Butter with 12 Hour Hold | Works with All Ethnicities & Hair Colors | Reduces Skin Irritation & Flaking - Invigorates Beard Growth | 60g
Price
$11.43
$12.99
$12.22
$14.98
Prime
Star Rating
-
-
-
Top Pick
Our Best Picks
Honest Amish Beard Balm Leave-in Conditioner - Made with only Natural and Organic Ingredients - 2 Ounce Tin
Title
Honest Amish Beard Balm Leave-in Conditioner - Made with only Natural and Organic Ingredients - 2 Ounce Tin
Price
$11.43
Prime
Star Rating
-
Details
Our Best Picks
Beard Balm - Rocky Mountain Barber - 100% Natural - Premium Wax Blend with Cedarwood Scent, Nutrient Rich Bees Wax, Jojoba, Tea Tree, Coconut Oil
Title
Beard Balm - Rocky Mountain Barber - 100% Natural - Premium Wax Blend with Cedarwood Scent, Nutrient Rich Bees Wax, Jojoba, Tea Tree, Coconut Oil
Price
$12.99
Prime
Star Rating
-
Details
Best Price
Our Best Picks
Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil - 2 Ounce
Title
Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil - 2 Ounce
Price
$12.22
Prime
Star Rating
Details
Our Best Picks
Styling Beard Balm - Organic and Moisturizing Beard Butter with 12 Hour Hold | Works with All Ethnicities & Hair Colors | Reduces Skin Irritation & Flaking - Invigorates Beard Growth | 60g
Title
Styling Beard Balm - Organic and Moisturizing Beard Butter with 12 Hour Hold | Works with All Ethnicities & Hair Colors | Reduces Skin Irritation & Flaking - Invigorates Beard Growth | 60g
Price
$14.98
Prime
Star Rating
-
Details

Feature image from Pinterest

You may also like